ARCHIVED TOPIC:
[ Line of Sight ]
DATE: December 31, 2001

Top 10 of 2001

Top10Well, it's the end of the year, and for some reason that makes people think about making lists. So why not a list of the top d20 products of the past year? Now, I made this list with a few caveats. First, it doesn't include anything that I worked on, because... well, that would seem a bit biased, eh? So, I leave it to someone else's listmaking skills to determine whether Return to the Temple, The Book of Eldritch Might, and so on, should go on a Top 10 somewhere.

Second, it's entirely possible that something came out so late in the year or simply slipped by me that was really great and deserves to be on the list. While I'm pretty aware of the whole d20 phenomenon, I haven't read absolutely everything.

Third, the order of the list is not as important as the list itself. While I think that the top ten products were pretty clear-cut, and even the top five were also clear-cut, there was no clear #1. Any of the top four or five could have been in the first slot and I really wouldn't blanche.

On to the list, counted down backwards, in David Letterman fashion. (The links below take you to the product's page on Amazon.com if you feel like giving any of them a try.)

10. Tome and Blood. The best, by far, of the Wizards class books. Imaginative prestige classes and cool spells. I recommend it.

9. Psionics Handbook. A few balance issues aside, this is one wonderfully imaginative and creative supplement. (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

8. Heart of Nightfang Spire. Everything you could want from a short dungeon adventure. Period. (Check out my review of this product.)

7. Legions of Hell. A great collection of fiends, with interesting monsters handled well rules-wise. If you like fiends, get your hands on this book. (Check out my review of this product.)

6. Manual of the Planes. A wonderful book, without a doubt. Others would rate it higher, I understand, but being as familiar with Planescape as I am, a lot of the coolness didn't seem as new to me. Still, a wonderful presentation and collection of material, and some great new stuff. (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

5. Relics & Rituals. This book is full of great spells. It has seen more use in my own campaign than any book beyond the core three. It would be higher on the list were it not for the priceless (no, not that sort of priceless) magic items. Chop that chapter off, and you've got one fantastic magic supplement. (Check out my review of this product.)

4. Oriental Adventures. Another great tome. Beautifully done, and covers all the necessary bases. It would be higher on the list were it not for some real balance problems (some high, some low) when compared to the core. (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

3. Traps & Treachery. Forget the stuff at the beginning and get this book for the Monster Manual-like presentation of imaginative and well-done traps. (Check out my review of this product.)

2. Magic of Faerun. Okay, so I like magic. While I might quibble here and there with a spell or two, this is full of great ideas and wonderful material -- and it's better balanced than most of its "competitors." (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

1. Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting. Probably the epitome of how a campaign setting should be presented. Chock full of interesting source material and game stuff. The game material probably raises the balance bar above that of the core, but FR has always been high-powered, whether Wizards is willing to admit it or not. (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

Extra bonus list: The Top Five Adventures.

Okay, the above list might be slightly skewed to favor sourcebooks over adventures. Given the same caveats as above, here are my favorite d20 adventures of the year:

5. In the Belly of the Beast (Check out the Atlas Games website.)

4. Speaker in Dreams (View the Wizards of the Coast product page.)

3. Demons & Devils (Check out my review of this product.)

2. To Stand on Hallowed Ground (Check out my review of this product.)

1. Heart of Nightfang Spire (Check out my review of this product.)

Happy New Year everyone! Like you, I'm excited to see what 2002 brings to my game shelf!

 
 
Questions or comments? Check out the Line of Sight message board.
 
Unless stated otherwise, all content © 2001 Monte Cook. All rights reserved.
 
The Unseelie Court - Proud sponsors of Ideabolt!
Grab an Ideabolt and start hurling.™